1.8 KiB
1.8 KiB
Review Output Template (Concise)
Use this template for review outputs. Keep each bullet short and implementable.
Context
- Surface: (web/app) + page type (list/detail/form/dashboard/settings)
- Primary user task:
- Primary CTA:
- Constraints/assumptions:
Diagnosis (pick one per major issue)
-
Execution gulf (执行鸿沟): user can’t find how to do it (entry/signifier/IA/choices)
-
Evaluation gulf (评估鸿沟): user can’t tell what happened (state/feedback/results)
-
Slip (失误): goal is correct, execution goes wrong (misclick, fat-finger, wrong target)
-
Mistake (错误): mental model is wrong (labels/mapping/conceptual model misleads)
Findings (prioritized)
P0 (blocker)
- Problem:
- Evidence:
- Diagnosis: execution gulf / evaluation gulf; slip / mistake
- Why it hurts:
- Fix (specific, implementable):
- Acceptance check:
P1 (important)
- Problem:
- Evidence:
- Diagnosis: execution gulf / evaluation gulf; slip / mistake
- Fix:
- Acceptance check:
P2 (polish)
- Problem:
- Diagnosis: execution gulf / evaluation gulf (optional)
- Fix:
Quick wins (optional)
- 3 small changes that noticeably improve clarity or polish.
Checklist to verify (copy/paste)
- Task clarity: primary CTA obvious and singular
- IA: groups and headings match mental model
- Feedback: loading/empty/error/success states present and helpful
- Consistency: components and wording stable across screens
- Affordance: clickable elements look clickable; icon-only is rare
- Errors: prevention + recovery + actionable messages
- Cognitive load: defaults and progressive disclosure reduce thinking
- CRAP: hierarchy, alignment, spacing, grouping feel intentional
- Modern minimal: restrained color, spacious layout, minimal copy
- Icons: no emoji; consistent set; labels where ambiguity exists